Merrick Dog Food Alternatives

Kibble for Canine Companions: Discovering Alternatives

Formulating Options to Merrick’s Popular Recipes

For those seeking alternatives to Merrick’s well-loved kibble, the search doesn’t have to be daunting.

Consider brands like Acana, which boasts a Red Meat Recipe Grain-Free Dog Food lauded for its high-quality ingredients and comprehensive nutrition. The recipe includes ranch-raised beef, Yorkshire pork, and grass-fed lamb, along with fruits and vegetables.

Another notable competitor is Taste of the Wild, offering an array of novel proteins much like Merrick. With formulas that cater to the wild instincts of canines, this brand brings flavors from the frontier to your furry friend’s bowl.

Grain-Free, Budget-Friendly Choices

Seeking to keep your pup happy while managing the purse strings can lead to discovering some excellent grain-free, budget-friendly alternatives.

Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain offers a range of cost-effective formulas, including their grain-free Turkey Meal & Sweet Potato recipe for dogs, delivering balanced nutrition without breaking the bank.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Made with real turkey as the first ingredient
    • Grain-free recipe which includes sweet potatoes and peas for digestible energy
    • Includes probiotics and prebiotic fiber for gut health
    • Contains antioxidants and omega fatty acids for a strong immune system and healthy coat
    • Competitive pricing without compromising on quality
  • Benefits:
    • Affordable grain-free option that doesn’t sacrifice nutritional value
    • Supports both digestive health and optimal skin and coat health
  • Cons:
    • Fewer protein variety options compared to more premium brands
    • May not be as widely available in all stores as some other brands

This product is best for dog owners who require grain-free nutrition for their pets but are also budget-conscious. Dogs with sensitivities or allergies to grains can benefit greatly from such a diet.

Another wallet-friendly alternative is the Pure Balance Grain-Free formula, which offers a blend of the necessary nutrients for a dog’s overall health without the inclusion of grains. It’s an excellent choice for pet owners who want a straightforward, no-fuss grain-free diet for their dogs.

Wet Food Wonders: Exploring Saucy Substitutes

Luxurious Broths and Hearty Stews

The delight of a savory stew or broth is not lost on our canine friends! Luxurious broths and hearty stews provide a wonderful sensory experience while delivering nutrition.

For those after a Merrick alternative, Blue Buffalo’s Homestyle Recipe is a strong contender. These canned foods boast real meat as the first ingredient, followed by garden fruits and vegetables, capturing a homestyle meal in every can.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Real meat, poultry, or fish is the first ingredient
    • Hearty, chunky textures that dogs love
    • No corn, wheat, soy, or chicken (or poultry) by-product meals
    • Blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals to support immune system health
    • No artificial flavors or preservatives
  • Benefits:
    • Mimics a home-cooked meal in taste and nutrition
    • Variety of recipes to keep your dog interested in their meals
  • Cons:
    • Slightly pricier than some other wet food options
    • Rich textures may not be suitable for all dogs, especially those with certain health conditions

Ideal for dogs who crave variety and a taste of home in their bowls, Blue Buffalo’s Homestyle Recipe stew cans are for pet owners wanting to provide their dogs with a rich, flavorful experience.

For a gourmet touch, consider Wellness CORE Hearty Cuts. Their shredded meats and rich gravy cater not only to taste but also encourage hydration, which is especially beneficial for dogs who might be reluctant water-drinkers.

Specialty Foods for Picky Pooches

Every pet parent knows the struggle of finding the right food for a picky eater. Sometimes, it takes a bit of culinary creativity to appease discerning palates. The Canidae PURE line is designed with such finicky four-leggers in mind.

With a focus on limited ingredients to reduce sensitivities, each formula boasts a simple recipe packed with quality protein and a taste that’s tough for any pooch to resist.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • A limited number of ingredients for sensitive dogs
    • A variety of protein sources including fish, lamb, duck, and bison
    • Grain-free options available
    • Contains probiotics for healthy digestion
    • Rich in antioxidants and omega-3 and 6 fatty acids for skin and coat health
  • Benefits:
    • Simplified recipes can ease the discomfort of dogs with food sensitivities
    • The exceptional taste that even picky eaters will love
  • Cons:
    • Limited ingredient diets may be more expensive than regular dog food
    • Some dogs might need time to adjust to the richer protein sources

Best for dogs who have turned up their noses at other brands or for those with sensitivities requiring a limited ingredient diet, Canidae PURE is a gourmet choice that doubles as a sensitive stomach-friendly option.

Another great selection for choosy canines is Orijen’s Biologically Appropriate Dog Food. Renowned for their “WholePrey” philosophy, Orijen incorporates fresh and raw animal ingredients, mimicking the natural dietary needs of dogs.

The rich diversity of meats, organs, and cartilage appeals to the instinctual preferences of many pups, likely scoring points with your persnickety pet.

Health and Wellness: Special Diets and Nutritional Needs

Nurturing Aging Dogs with Senior-Specific Brands

As our furry friends enter their golden years, it’s essential to support them with tailored nutrition. Blue Buffalo’s Life Protection Formula for seniors is a sterling example, crafted with older dogs in mind.

These kibbles include “LifeSource Bits,” a precise blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals to boost overall health and wellness in older dogs.

With enhanced ingredients such as glucosamine for joint health and increased protein, Blue Buffalo caters to the distinct needs of aging canines.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Includes glucosamine and chondroitin for healthy joints
    • Increased protein levels to maintain muscle mass
    • Features Blue Buffalo’s exclusive LifeSource Bits for antioxidants
    • Formulated with high-quality, natural ingredients
    • Devoid of corn, wheat, soy, or chicken by-product meals
  • Benefits:
    • Specifically designed for the dietary needs of senior dogs
    • Promotes mobility and overall health through added nutrients
  • Cons:
    • The unique smell of the food may not be appealing to all owners or dogs
    • May be costlier compared to standard adult dog foods

This product is ideal for senior dogs that require a diet crafted to their changing nutritional needs, especially those in need of joint support and a little mental boost.

Meanwhile, brands like Royal Canin offer a sophisticated selection tailored to the life stage of your dog.

They provide customized nutrition for not just seniors but puppies, adults, and those with special conditions, assuring a match for your dog’s specific life stage and dietary requirements.

Catering to Canines with Sensitive Stomachs

For pups with sensitive stomachs, finding a food that’s gentle but also nutritious is key. You might want to consider the ACANA Singles line which offers limited ingredient, grain-free options with a single-source protein.

Their dedication to providing easy-to-digest meals helps soothe sensitive stomachs while still offering a rich variety of flavors.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Single-source protein for easier digestion
    • Includes locally sourced fruits and vegetables
    • No grain, gluten, potato, or tapioca, catering to a range of dietary sensitivities
    • Infusions of freeze-dried liver for palatability
    • Nutritionally complete to support overall health
  • Benefits:
    • Tailored for dogs with dietary sensitivities or allergies
    • Nutrient-dense, supporting overall wellbeing with fewer ingredients
  • Cons:
    • Premium pricing may be a consideration for budget-conscious pet owners
    • Some dogs may need to be transitioned gradually due to the richness of single-source proteins

Best for pet owners who prioritize a limited ingredient diet for their dogs with sensitive stomachs, ACANA Singles is dedicated to meeting nutritional needs while minimizing potential digestive upset.

Another palatable choice in this category is Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dog Food. Their recipes are specifically designed to provide complete and balanced nutrition with a minimal number of protein and carbohydrate sources.

This simplicity can be particularly beneficial for dogs with finicky digestive systems.

Breed and Size Specific Solutions

Little Bites: Foods Fit for Small Breeds

Small breed dogs have big nutritional needs packed into their tiny statures. They typically require calorie-dense food that supports their rapid metabolisms while ensuring that each mouthful is manageable for smaller jaws.

Wellness CORE Grain-Free Small Breed is a fantastic Merrick alternative. With turkey and chicken as the primary proteins and kibble size perfect for little mouths, this food addresses the unique dietary needs of smaller breeds.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Higher protein and fat levels suitable for small breed energy needs
    • Small kibble size tailored for tiny mouths
    • Grain-free and full of nutrient-rich ingredients
    • Includes probiotics, antioxidants, omega fatty acids, and more for comprehensive health
    • No meat by-products, fillers, or artificial preservatives
  • Benefits:
    • Supports higher energy needs of small breeds with appropriate calorie content
    • Promotes whole-body health with balanced nutrition
  • Cons:
    • May be pricier than some other small breed formulas
    • Grain-free diet may not be suitable for all dogs; consultation with a vet is recommended

Wellness CORE Grain-Free Small Breed is best for pet owners who are looking for premium, grain-free nutrition specially formulated for the needs of their small breed dogs.

Another product to consider is Nutro Ultra Small Breed Adult Dry Dog Food. This ‘superfood’ blend includes a trio of proteins from chicken, lamb, and salmon to provide optimal nutrition.

The inclusion of a variety of superfoods like coconut, chia, and kale ensures that your little one gets all the vitamins and minerals they need.

Large Breed Formulas: Meeting the Demands of Bigger Dogs

Large breed dogs come with appetites and nutritional needs that are just as grand as their size.

Keep them thriving with diet options that cater to their higher caloric needs to support their larger bodies while fostering joint health and lean muscle maintenance.

The Taste of the Wild PREY Angus Beef Limited Ingredient Recipe is a robust choice that provides high-quality, single-source protein, specialized for the dietary needs of larger breeds.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • A simple ingredient list that reduces the risk of food sensitivities
    • High-quality Angus beef as the first ingredient for lean protein
    • Includes guaranteed probiotics for digestive health
    • Tomato pomace and lentils deliver fiber and beneficial nutrients
    • No grain, GMO ingredients, or artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives
  • Benefits:
    • Satisfies the appetite of large breed dogs with nutrient-dense, high-protein kibble
    • Promotes healthy digestion and is ideal for dogs with sensitive systems
  • Cons:
    • Limited flavor variety may not suit all preferences
    • Some owners may prefer a food with a wider range of ingredients

Especially for large breed dogs who might have sensitivities or allergies, Taste of the Wild PREY creates a diet that is both nutritious and limited in ingredients to avoid common triggers.

For those prioritizing joint health, also consider Wellness CORE Grain-Free Large Breed Chicken & Turkey Recipe.

This specific formula is enhanced with natural sources of glucosamine and chondroitin, which are essential for maintaining healthy joints in massive breeds. The high protein content helps these gentle giants maintain lean muscle mass, too.

The Future of Feeding: Subscription Services and Novel Trends

Customized Meal Plans Delivered to Your Doorstep

Say goodbye to generic bags of dog food and hello to a custom-tailored feast for your furry friend!

Subscription services like Spot & Tango offer a new wave of convenience and personalized nutrition in the world of dog food.

With the promise of tailoring dog meals to individual needs based on factors such as age, weight, breed, and health concerns, Spot & Tango delivers Unkibble or fresh dog food directly to your doorstep.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Customized meal plans based on your dog’s unique profile
    • Options for fresh meals or dry food (Unkibble) made with whole ingredients
    • Recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists
    • Convenient home delivery with flexible scheduling
    • Environmentally friendly with sustainable packaging and practices
  • Benefits:
    • Ensures your dog’s diet is optimized for their health and preferences
    • Saves time on shopping and meal prep for busy pet owners
  • Cons:
    • Subscription services can be more expensive compared to traditional dog food
    • Requires fridge or freezer space for storing fresh meal portions

Spot & Tango’s meal plans are best for dogs with specific dietary needs or discerning eaters, as well as for owners seeking the utmost convenience in managing their dog’s diet.

This hands-off approach to pet nutrition is also embraced by services like The Farmer’s Dog, which crafts recipes that are pre-portioned and ready to serve upon arrival. They emphasize fresh, human-grade food that caters to both taste and health.

Embracing The Raw and Freeze-Dried Revolution

The raw and freeze-dried food trend is revolutionizing the pet food aisle with options that promise a diet closer to what dogs might eat in the wild.

For those interested in diving into this trend, consider brands like Stella & Chewy’s, which offers a lineup of freeze-dried raw meals that maintain nutritional integrity while providing the convenience of a shelf-stable food.

  • Top 5 Features:
    • Freeze-dried raw meat is the primary ingredient.
    • Enhanced with organic fruits and vegetables.
    • Includes added taurine, probiotics, and other beneficial supplements.
    • Free from grains, gluten, fillers, artificial colors, or preservatives.
    • Variety of protein options to suit different tastes and dietary needs.
  • Benefits:
    • Mimics a dog’s ancestral diet, potentially offering improved digestion and vitality.
    • Convenient to store and serve, no refrigeration required after opening.
  • Cons:
    • Typically costlier than traditional kibble or wet foods.
    • Portion sizes may need to be adjusted according to the caloric density.

Ideal for dog owners seeking a more ‘natural’ diet for their pets or those eager to test the potential health benefits of raw food without the mess, Stella & Chewy’s provides a high-quality introduction to the raw food movement.

Another pioneering brand in this category is Primal Pet Foods, which emphasizes the importance of whole-food formulas.

Their Freeze-Dried Nuggets offer the ease of a scoop-and-serve meal with the nutritional benefits of raw ingredients, solidifying their place as a leader in the raw food wave.

FAQs: Everyday Questions About Dog Food Alternatives

What Should I Look for When Selecting a Dog Food Brand?

When selecting a dog food brand, it’s important to start with a quality protein source as the first ingredient.

Check that the formula is balanced and meets the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO.

Also, consider your dog’s life stage, size, and any specific health needs. Ingredients should be wholesome and free from unnecessary fillers or artificial preservatives. Lastly, take note of the brand’s reputation for safety and quality assurance.

How Do I Transition My Dog to a New Food?

Transitioning your dog to a new food should be done gradually over 7 to 10 days. Start by mixing 25% of the new food with 75% of the old food for 2-3 days.

If your dog adjusts well, increase to a 50/50 mix. Continue to monitor their response, and if all is well, move to 75% new food and 25% old, until you’ve completely switched over. Watch for any signs of digestive upset and adjust the pace if needed.

Photo of author

AUTHOR

Austin Affor, owner and principal editor of DogFoodFocus.com, uses the latest scientific research to provide evidence-based advice on dog care and nutrition. Inspired by his 12-year-old Rottweiler, Frisky, he emphasizes the importance of a healthy diet and shares his expertise to promote pet wellness.

Save 30% on your next dog food order!

We have partnered with Chewy.com to offer the best deal on high-quality dog food to our readers. If you click on the button below, we will take you to their exclusive discount page.